How to Engage Students in the Classroom: 8 Strategies for College Instructors
“How do you choose a teammate?”
I like to open a class with a question students have already faced. When someone says, “I’d choose my friends,” I might ask, “Have you ever picked a friend for a team and found yourself doing most of the work?”
That second question is where the discussion gets interesting. One student might value a friend they can be honest with. Another might remember how hard it was to tell a friend they had missed a deadline. I have ideas I want the class to explore, but students can leave with different questions and still have made good use of the conversation.
To engage students in the classroom, give them something specific to notice, decide, explain, or try. Then use what they contribute to shape the next few minutes of teaching. Here are eight ways to do that in a college class.
1. Start with a decision students have actually faced
A first-year student may have little to say about “criteria for effective team formation.” The same student probably has an opinion about who they would trust with a group project due on Friday. Before planning your opening slide, think about where students have already encountered the day’s topic.
Give everyone a moment to settle on an answer. Invite a few responses and keep one or two of the students’ own phrases on the board. For the teammate discussion, leave “I’d pick a friend” visible while you introduce two projects: a prototype due tomorrow and a six-month assignment with a client.
Ask students to revisit their choice. Does knowing someone well matter in the same way for both projects? Their reasoning gives you a way into trust, reliability, and complementary skills. You can introduce those terms once the class has a use for them.
2. Give students something to notice before you explain it
In a statistics lecture, display two line charts showing a score rising from 94 to 97. Give one chart a vertical axis that starts at zero and the other an axis that starts at 90. Label both axes clearly. Ask students to write a headline for each chart.
Read two headlines aloud. One might describe a small improvement while another announces a sharp rise. Now draw attention to the scales. Students have experienced a reason to inspect an axis before interpreting a trend.
You can use the same technique with two translations of a sentence, two photographs of a public space, or two ways of displaying a price. Choose a difference that leads into the concept you plan to teach, and leave a few seconds of silence for students to see it.
3. Follow an incomplete answer far enough to understand it
When a student offers a partial answer, find out what they meant before you evaluate it. Suppose someone says, “I’d choose the most talented person for my team.” Any one of these follow-ups could move the discussion forward:
- “What would you look for as evidence of talent?”
- “Would you use the same criterion if the deadline were tomorrow?”
- “Can you think of a project where that choice would work especially well?”
Choose one and give the student time to answer. If there’s a factual error, correct it clearly. If the answer is simply broad, the follow-up gives the student a chance to make it more precise. How you handle that first contribution also tells everyone else what to expect when they speak.
4. Let everyone form an answer before taking volunteers
In a large lecture, one confident volunteer can set the direction of a discussion before most of the room has formed an opinion. Give students a minute to write first.
For example, put this prompt on screen in an economics class: “The campus café raises the price of coffee by 10%. What would you need to know to predict whether its revenue will rise?” Ask each student to write down one piece of information, then compare answers with a neighbor.
Bring the room back together with, “Who heard an idea from their partner that they hadn’t considered?” To see whether students can apply the reasoning independently, change the setting to the only café in an airport terminal and ask which assumption they would revisit.
Smith and colleagues studied a similar distinction: after students discussed a concept question with peers, they answered a related question individually. Read the study on peer discussion and conceptual understanding.
5. Plan the discussion before assigning the exercise
I once gave students a practical exercise and ran out of time to review their work. The class drifted into playing games on their phones. These days, when I decide whether an exercise belongs in class, I count the time we’ll need to look at what students did. If there’s no room for that conversation, I assign it as homework.
Before setting a task, finish this sentence: “When everyone comes back together, we’ll look at ___ and use it to ___.”
For a writing class, that could be: “We’ll look at two versions of the same email and identify the sentence that makes the next step clear.” Now students know what to produce, and you know how to bring the room back together. Two examples may be enough.
Does this activity fit today’s class?
- What will students produce?
- Which responses will we look at together?
- How much time have I reserved to discuss them?
Cornell’s teaching guide also recommends explaining an activity’s purpose and setting aside time afterward for feedback. Explore Cornell’s guide to active learning techniques.
6. Put the evidence in students’ hands
A paragraph, a table, a photograph, or a few lines of code can give everyone in the room something to investigate. Choose a sample small enough that students can examine it during class.
In a history seminar, show two accounts of the same event. Ask each student to underline one phrase that reveals the writer’s perspective. They can compare phrases with a partner, submit theirs in writing, or volunteer to explain their choice. When someone offers an interpretation, the class can return to the words that prompted it.
In a programming course, show a short function and ask students to supply one input that would expose a bug. Run two of their suggestions. Which one triggered the error, and why? The examples give you a window into students’ thinking, including contributions from people who rarely speak.
A large review by Freeman and colleagues found that active learning improved student performance across undergraduate STEM courses. Read the active learning meta-analysis.
7. Ask for feedback while there’s still time to act on it
After a difficult example, try asking, “Which step would you like to see again with different numbers?” The question gives students something specific to recall and gives you a decision you can make before the next class.
Then show students what happened to their input. You might open the next session with, “Several of you followed the calculation but weren’t sure why I chose that formula. Let’s compare two problems where the choice is different.”
Instructors using AtKlass can collect anonymous classroom feedback and review class ratings. Read the comments alongside the response count. A concern raised by three students can be worth addressing, even when you still need to find out how widely it’s shared.
8. End with a question students can take with them
At the end of the team-selection discussion, give students a minute to respond to this prompt: “The next time you choose a teammate, what’s one thing you’ll want to find out first?”
Students can keep the response. If you’d like to use a few to open the next session, ask for volunteers to share theirs. One student may leave thinking about reliability; another may start wondering what they themselves bring to a team.
For a technical lesson, try: “What would have to change for today’s solution to stop working?” The answers can reveal which assumptions students noticed and which ones deserve another look.
How can you tell if students are engaged?
Choose the signal that matches what you want to know. Attendance tells you who had the opportunity to participate. Students’ questions, written work, and explanations give you a closer look at what they did with that opportunity.
| What you want to know | What to look at | How to use it |
|---|---|---|
| Who had the opportunity to participate? | Attendance for that session | Put responses in context. Thirty answers mean something different in a class of 35 than in a lecture of 150. |
| How broadly did students participate? | Individual notes, poll responses, annotations, or examples | If contributions came from a small group, give everyone a brief individual task before the next discussion. |
| What did students experience? | Responses to a focused feedback prompt | Identify a recurring difficulty and ask a more specific follow-up. |
| Can students apply the concept? | An explanation, revision, or solution to a fresh problem | Find the step that needs another example, then check it again. |
Students’ perceptions and their learning can tell different parts of the story. In a university physics study, Deslauriers and colleagues found that students in an active-learning class learned more even though they felt they had learned less. When an exercise feels difficult, students’ comments can help locate the difficulty. Their work can help you decide what to do about it. Read the study on actual and perceived learning.
Frequently asked questions
How do you engage quiet students without putting them on the spot?
Give students a specific contribution to make and a choice about how to share it. Ask everyone to highlight the least convincing sentence in an argument. They can discuss it with a partner, submit a note, or volunteer to explain their choice. Each option gives you a way to see their thinking.
How do you keep students engaged during a long lecture?
Find a point where your next slide would answer a question. Pause one slide earlier. Let students inspect the evidence, predict the outcome, or sketch the next step. When you reveal the answer, return to one of their predictions so they can compare it with what happened.
What’s one change I can make for my next class?
Pick one moment when you usually ask, “Does that make sense?” Try, “Write down the first step you’d take on this new example.” Leave time to look at a few responses. What students write will help you decide whether to move on or explain that step another way.